Xj3D Implementation Status

This product conforms to the X3D 3.0 Interchange Profile.

This page will detail the progress of the Xj3D project in implementing the X3D and VRML97 specifications. It will be used to self-report our compliance with the specifications and to document where work is needed in the project.

Definitions:

Conforms - A node/feature has been proven to be compliant with all Web3D published conformance tests
Complete - A node/feature has been implemented and tested locally
Partial - A node/feature had been implemented but has restrictions or missing field handling
None - This node/feature has not been implemented. Care to fix that?

One of our major goals is to be 100% compliant with the specifications we implement. Having an open source implementation available for all specification implementators will make all Web3D content more interoperable. We continually need help in running conformance tests to keep this table accurate. If you think an item is inaccurate, please post to the source list.

Xj3D has been tested by the Web3D Consortium and conforms to the X3D Interchange profile. As further tests become available we will have Xj3D tested against more profiles.

Score Card

These results are posted by renderer. Currently Xj3D supports four renderers: Java3D, OpenGL, mobile device and the null renderer. Null renderer results are not posted as they should work for any node implemented in any other renderer.

These results where last updated on 25 January 2006, released as 1.1. 2.0 results will be posted after the first formal release.

OpenGL Renderer

Profile Conforms Complete Partial None

Interchange 98% (46/47) 100% (46) 0% (0) 0% (0)

Interactive 13% (5/38) 89% (34) 11% (4) 0% (0)

Immersive 7% (6/86) 86% (74) 8% (7) 1% (1)

Java3D Renderer

Profile Compliant Complete Partial None

Interchange 18% (5/28) 100% (28) 0% (0) 0% (0)

Interactive 13% (5/38) 92% (35) 8% (3) 0% (0)

MPEG-4 Interactive 13% (5/38) 92% (35) 8% (3) 0% (0)

Immersive 7% (6/86) 86% (74) 9% (8) 0% (0)

Mobile Renderer

Profile Conforms Complete Partial None

Interchange 0% (0/28) 50% (14) 11% (3) 39% (11)

Interactive 0% (0/38) 37% (14) 8% (3) 55% (21)

MPEG-4 Interactive 0% (0/38) 37% (14) 8% (3) 55% (21)

Immersive 0% (0/54) 28% (15) 6% (3) 67% (36)

OpenGL Renderer
Profile	Conforms	Complete	Partial	None
Interchange	98% (46/47)	100% (46)	0% (0)	0% (0)
Interactive	13% (5/38)	89% (34)	11% (4)	0% (0)
Immersive	7% (6/86)	86% (74)	8% (7)	1% (1)

Java3D Renderer
Profile	Compliant	Complete	Partial	None
Interchange	18% (5/28)	100% (28)	0% (0)	0% (0)
Interactive	13% (5/38)	92% (35)	8% (3)	0% (0)
MPEG-4 Interactive	13% (5/38)	92% (35)	8% (3)	0% (0)
Immersive	7% (6/86)	86% (74)	9% (8)	0% (0)

Mobile Renderer
Profile	Conforms	Complete	Partial	None
Interchange	0% (0/28)	50% (14)	11% (3)	39% (11)
Interactive	0% (0/38)	37% (14)	8% (3)	55% (21)
MPEG-4 Interactive	0% (0/38)	37% (14)	8% (3)	55% (21)
Immersive	0% (0/54)	28% (15)	6% (3)	67% (36)

Node Status

Status of the nodes that belong to both VRML97 and X3D v3.0. Nodes for later amendments are catalogued separately below.

These results where last updated on April 22 2006, 1.0 Release.

Node Java3D OpenGL Mobile

Anchor Complete Complete None

Appearance Complete Conforms Complete

Arc2D None None None

ArcClose2D None None None

AudioClip Complete Complete None

Background Complete Conforms None

Billboard Complete Complete None

BooleanFilter Complete Complete None

BooleanSequencer Complete Complete None

BooleanToggle Complete Complete None

BooleanTrigger Complete Complete None

Box Complete Conforms Complete

Circle2D None None None

Collision Partial Complete None

Color Conforms Conforms None

ColorInterpolator Conforms Conforms Conforms

ColorRGBA Complete Complete None

Cone Complete Conforms None

Contour2D None None None

ContourPolyline2D None None None

Coordinate Conforms Conforms None

CoordinateDouble None None None

CoordinateInterpolator Conforms Conforms Conforms

CoordinateInterpolator2D Conforms Conforms Conforms

Cylinder Complete Conforms None

CylinderSensor Partial Partial None

DirectionalLight Complete Conforms None

Disk2D None None None

ElevationGrid Complete Complete None

EspduTransform Partial Partial None

Extrusion Complete Partial None

FillProperties Partial Partial None

Fog Complete Complete None

FontStyle Complete Complete Complete

GeoCoordinate Complete Complete None

GeoElevationGrid Complete Complete None

GeoLocation Complete Complete None

GeoLOD None Complete None

GeoMetadata Complete Complete None

GeoOrigin Complete Complete None

GeoPositionInterpolator Complete Complete None

GeoTouchSensor Complete Complete None

GeoViewpoint Partial Partial None

Group Complete Conforms Complete

HAnimDisplacer None Complete None

HAnimHumanoid None Complete None

HAnimJoint None Complete None

HAnimSegment None Complete None

HAnimSite None Complete None

ImageTexture Complete Conforms None

IndexedFaceSet Complete Conforms Partial

IndexedLineSet Complete Conforms None

IndexedTriangleFanSet Complete Conforms None

IndexedTriangleSet Complete Conforms None

IndexedTriangleStripSet Complete Complete None

Inline Complete Complete Complete

IntegerSequencer Complete Complete None

IntegerTrigger Complete Complete None

LineProperties Complete Complete None

LineSet None Conforms None

LoadSensor Complete Complete Complete

LOD Complete Complete None

KeySensor Complete Complete Complete

Material Complete Conforms Complete

MetadataDouble Complete Conforms None

MetadataFloat Complete Conforms None

MetadataInteger Complete Conforms None

MetadataSet Complete Conforms None

MetadataString Complete Conforms None

MovieTexture Partial Partial None

MultiTexture Partial Partial None

MultiTextureCoordinate Complete Conforms None

MultiTextureTransform Complete Conforms None

NavigationInfo Complete Conforms Partial

Normal Complete Conforms None

NormalInterpolator Conforms Conforms Conforms

NurbsCurve None None None

NurbsCurve2D None None None

NurbsOrientationInterpolator None None None

NurbsPatchSurface None None None

NurbsPositionInterpolator None None None

NurbsSet None None None

NurbsSurfaceInterpolator None None None

NurbsSweptSurface None None None

NurbsSwungSurface None None None

NurbsTextureCoordinate None None None

NurbsTrimmedSurface None None None

OrientationInterpolator Conforms Conforms Conforms

PixelTexture Complete Conforms None

PlaneSensor Partial Complete None

PointLight Complete Complete None

PointSet Complete Conforms None

Polyline2D Complete Complete None

Polypoint2D Complete Complete None

PositionInterpolator Conforms Conforms Conforms

PositionInterpolator2D Conforms Conforms Conforms

ProximitySensor Complete Complete None

ReceiverPdu None None None

Rectangle2D Complete Complete None

ScalarInterpolator Conforms Conforms Conforms

Script Complete Complete Complete

Shape Complete Conforms Complete

SignalPdu None None None

Sound Partial Complete None

Sphere Complete Conforms Complete

SphereSensor Complete Complete None

SpotLight Complete Complete None

StaticGroup Complete Complete None

StringSensor Complete Complete Complete

Switch Complete Complete None

Text Partial Partial None

TextureBackground None None None

TextureCoordinate Complete Conforms None

TextureCoordinateGenerator Complete Conforms None

TextureTransform Complete Conforms None

TimeSensor Complete Conforms Complete

TimeTrigger Complete Complete None

TouchSensor Partial Complete None

Transform Complete Conforms Complete

TransmitterPdu None None None

TriangleFanSet Complete Conforms None

TriangleSet Complete Conforms None

TriangleSet2D Complete Conforms None

TriangleStripSet Complete Conforms None

Viewpoint Complete Conforms Partial

VisibilitySensor Complete Complete None

WorldInfo Conforms Conforms Conforms

Node	Java3D	OpenGL	Mobile
Anchor	Complete	Complete	None
Appearance	Complete	Conforms	Complete
Arc2D	None	None	None
ArcClose2D	None	None	None
AudioClip	Complete	Complete	None
Background	Complete	Conforms	None
Billboard	Complete	Complete	None
BooleanFilter	Complete	Complete	None
BooleanSequencer	Complete	Complete	None
BooleanToggle	Complete	Complete	None
BooleanTrigger	Complete	Complete	None
Box	Complete	Conforms	Complete
Circle2D	None	None	None
Collision	Partial	Complete	None
Color	Conforms	Conforms	None
ColorInterpolator	Conforms	Conforms	Conforms
ColorRGBA	Complete	Complete	None
Cone	Complete	Conforms	None
Contour2D	None	None	None
ContourPolyline2D	None	None	None
Coordinate	Conforms	Conforms	None
CoordinateDouble	None	None	None
CoordinateInterpolator	Conforms	Conforms	Conforms
CoordinateInterpolator2D	Conforms	Conforms	Conforms
Cylinder	Complete	Conforms	None
CylinderSensor	Partial	Partial	None
DirectionalLight	Complete	Conforms	None
Disk2D	None	None	None
ElevationGrid	Complete	Complete	None
EspduTransform	Partial	Partial	None
Extrusion	Complete	Partial	None
FillProperties	Partial	Partial	None
Fog	Complete	Complete	None
FontStyle	Complete	Complete	Complete
GeoCoordinate	Complete	Complete	None
GeoElevationGrid	Complete	Complete	None
GeoLocation	Complete	Complete	None
GeoLOD	None	Complete	None
GeoMetadata	Complete	Complete	None
GeoOrigin	Complete	Complete	None
GeoPositionInterpolator	Complete	Complete	None
GeoTouchSensor	Complete	Complete	None
GeoViewpoint	Partial	Partial	None
Group	Complete	Conforms	Complete
HAnimDisplacer	None	Complete	None
HAnimHumanoid	None	Complete	None
HAnimJoint	None	Complete	None
HAnimSegment	None	Complete	None
HAnimSite	None	Complete	None
ImageTexture	Complete	Conforms	None
IndexedFaceSet	Complete	Conforms	Partial
IndexedLineSet	Complete	Conforms	None
IndexedTriangleFanSet	Complete	Conforms	None
IndexedTriangleSet	Complete	Conforms	None
IndexedTriangleStripSet	Complete	Complete	None
Inline	Complete	Complete	Complete
IntegerSequencer	Complete	Complete	None
IntegerTrigger	Complete	Complete	None
LineProperties	Complete	Complete	None
LineSet	None	Conforms	None
LoadSensor	Complete	Complete	Complete
LOD	Complete	Complete	None
KeySensor	Complete	Complete	Complete
Material	Complete	Conforms	Complete
MetadataDouble	Complete	Conforms	None
MetadataFloat	Complete	Conforms	None
MetadataInteger	Complete	Conforms	None
MetadataSet	Complete	Conforms	None
MetadataString	Complete	Conforms	None
MovieTexture	Partial	Partial	None
MultiTexture	Partial	Partial	None
MultiTextureCoordinate	Complete	Conforms	None
MultiTextureTransform	Complete	Conforms	None
NavigationInfo	Complete	Conforms	Partial
Normal	Complete	Conforms	None
NormalInterpolator	Conforms	Conforms	Conforms
NurbsCurve	None	None	None
NurbsCurve2D	None	None	None
NurbsOrientationInterpolator	None	None	None
NurbsPatchSurface	None	None	None
NurbsPositionInterpolator	None	None	None
NurbsSet	None	None	None
NurbsSurfaceInterpolator	None	None	None
NurbsSweptSurface	None	None	None
NurbsSwungSurface	None	None	None
NurbsTextureCoordinate	None	None	None
NurbsTrimmedSurface	None	None	None
OrientationInterpolator	Conforms	Conforms	Conforms
PixelTexture	Complete	Conforms	None
PlaneSensor	Partial	Complete	None
PointLight	Complete	Complete	None
PointSet	Complete	Conforms	None
Polyline2D	Complete	Complete	None
Polypoint2D	Complete	Complete	None
PositionInterpolator	Conforms	Conforms	Conforms
PositionInterpolator2D	Conforms	Conforms	Conforms
ProximitySensor	Complete	Complete	None
ReceiverPdu	None	None	None
Rectangle2D	Complete	Complete	None
ScalarInterpolator	Conforms	Conforms	Conforms
Script	Complete	Complete	Complete
Shape	Complete	Conforms	Complete
SignalPdu	None	None	None
Sound	Partial	Complete	None
Sphere	Complete	Conforms	Complete
SphereSensor	Complete	Complete	None
SpotLight	Complete	Complete	None
StaticGroup	Complete	Complete	None
StringSensor	Complete	Complete	Complete
Switch	Complete	Complete	None
Text	Partial	Partial	None
TextureBackground	None	None	None
TextureCoordinate	Complete	Conforms	None
TextureCoordinateGenerator	Complete	Conforms	None
TextureTransform	Complete	Conforms	None
TimeSensor	Complete	Conforms	Complete
TimeTrigger	Complete	Complete	None
TouchSensor	Partial	Complete	None
Transform	Complete	Conforms	Complete
TransmitterPdu	None	None	None
TriangleFanSet	Complete	Conforms	None
TriangleSet	Complete	Conforms	None
TriangleSet2D	Complete	Conforms	None
TriangleStripSet	Complete	Conforms	None
Viewpoint	Complete	Conforms	Partial
VisibilitySensor	Complete	Complete	None
WorldInfo	Conforms	Conforms	Conforms

Amendment 1 node status

Node	Java3D	OpenGL	Mobile
TextureMatrixTransform	None	None	None
TextureTransform3D	None	Complete	None
TextureCoordinate3D	None	Complete	None
TextureCoordinate4D	None	Complete	None
Composed3DTexture	None	None	None
Pixel3DTexture	None	None	None
Image3DTexture	None	None	None
ComposedCubeMapTexture	None	None	None
PixelCubeMapTexture	None	None	None
ImageCubeMapTexture	None	None	None
GeneratedCubeMapTexture	None	None	None
FogCoordinate	None	Complete	None
LocalFog	None	Complete	None
FloatVertexAttribute	None	None	None
ComposedShader	None	None	None
ShaderPart	None	None	None
ProgramShader	None	None	None
ShaderProgram	None	None	None
Matrix3VertexAttribute	None	None	None
Matrix4VertexAttribute	None	None	None
PackagedShader	None	None	None

Amendment 2 node status

Node	Java3D	OpenGL	Mobile

Abstract Spec Functionality

Feature	Conformance
DEF/USE	Conforms
Route	Complete
Scripting - JSAI (VRML97)	Complete
Scripting - JavaScript (VRML97)	Complete
EAI (VRML97)	Complete
SAI (X3D - Internal)	Partial
SAI (X3D - External)	Partial
Prototypes	Complete
Extern Prototypes	Complete
URN Resolution	Complete
PROFILE	Conforms
COMPONENT	Conforms
META	Conforms
IMPORT/EXPORT	Complete

Language Encodings

Feature	VRML97	X3D-VRML	X3D-XML	X3D-Binary
Basic lexical parsing	Complete	Complete	Complete	Complete
DEF/USE	Complete	Complete	Complete	Complete
Route	Complete	Complete	Complete	Complete
Scripts	Complete	Complete	Complete
Prototypes	Complete	Complete	Complete
Extern Prototypes	Complete	Complete	Complete
URN Resolution	Complete	Complete	Complete	Complete
PROFILE	N/A	Complete	Complete	Complete
COMPONENT	N/A	Complete	Complete	Complete
META	N/A	Complete	Complete	Complete
IMPORT/EXPORT	N/A	Complete	Complete

Node Implementation Notes

Collision: Java3D - proxy field not handled. Collides always based on raw geometry
CylinderSensor: autoOffset not quite calculated correctly
EspduTransform: Still working on some of the lesser-used fields.
Extrusion: OpenGL version does not handle end caps correctly, nor creaseAngle.
FillProperties: The hatching definition in the spec is completely borked. No idea how its even supposed to be implemented. Is it in image-space, world space, what happens if there are other textures etc.
GeoViewpoint: Height-based speed and range scaling not correctly scaled. Auto visibilityLimit not sure what to do, NavigationInfo side not tested.
GeoElevationGrid: creaseAngle not handled
MovieTexture: JMF is extremely problematic. Doesn't work most of the time. Going to have to look into alternate video encoding strategies as JMF will only support a single stream running at a time (which is spec-compliant, but almost useless). Maybe have to start a Java binding to OpenML?
MultiTexture: Not all the modes are transcribed to the underlying API
PlaneSensor: autoOffset not quite calculated correctly
Sound: Java3D's sound handling is very dodgy. For Java3D 1.3.2 and later, sound is most likely to be disabled completely.
SphereSensor: autoOffset not quite calculated correctly
Text: length and maxExtents not handled. No testing with non-latin character sets.
TouchSensor: Normal and texCoord outputs not generated